I wouldn't say that I am a Twlight fan, but I did enjoy Stephanie Meyer's first 3 books and I even enjoyed The Host, but Breaking Dawn was a disappointment!! I don't want to ruin the book for anyone so I won't give anything away, but when everyone else finishes it and wants to talk about it let me know....FYI- If you have kids, I wouldn't let them read this one
oh no! i havent read any of them, but thats terrible! after all the awesome things everyone has said about the previous 3! thats too bad.
ReplyDeleteI can't believe you've already read it! I haven't even been able to get to the store to buy it today! And I'm a super huge fan, she's in my parents ward, crazy! But, man, I hope it's just you... I'll be ready to discuss shortly...
ReplyDeleteSo I pre-ordered my book from Amazon and they are supposed to have the book to you the day it comes out, but UPS doesn't deliver on Saturday so I won't get my copy until Monday. I am because I was hoping to read it this weekend when I actually have time. I can't believe you are done already! Did you stay up all night and read it. So far you aren't the only one I have heard who didn't like it, which makes me sad. Although I am hoping that since I have heard so many negative things my expectations will be lower and then I will like it ;) I will hopefully be up for a discussion soon!
ReplyDeletebig sis, I am so sad that you didn't love it. I will admit that I was a big fan!!!! I don't want to talk about the details here but we will have to catch up. I miss you!!!
ReplyDeletewell Lisa, I am sad to say it, but I too was disappointed. And I am a total fan! No spoilers, but it just didn't seem to fit. The end picked up for me, though.
ReplyDeleteI agree about not letting kids read it. It was a bit anti climatic. I give it a C+
ReplyDeleteOkay, so I guess I will finish the 3rd book, so I can read the 4th. Wish me luck!! I have heard very mixed reviews, mainly falling on the anti climatic side. Ah...I'm glad no one is giving it away!
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteAHHHHHHH! I'm only like half way through...and can't wait to keep going, then I'll FINALLY call you back and we can discuss!
ReplyDeleteso i am only 200 pages in and i have to say i am surprised about how much i like it, i mean i heard awful things about the book so i didnt have high expectations but seriously this is SIGNIFICANTLY better than the last two, i still want to slap the girl but we'll see how i feel by the end.
ReplyDeleteI just finished it. I liked it, but agree with Beth, a bit anti-climactic. Is it morbid of me to want something, some sort of fight, to have happened. A little too much happily ever after for me. But I still liked it. How can you go wrong with Edward ;)
ReplyDeleteOh we have to talk I just finished the other day. I have to say I didn't think it was great either, but really sometimes by the forth book how great can it be??
ReplyDeleteI wanted more action, fighting, and emotion. Was anyone REALLY surprised by anything that happened? It was so much more predictable than Stephanie Meyer's others. Oh well, can't win them all!!
ReplyDelete